Flack Capital Markets | Ferrous Financial Insider

March 14, 2025 – Issue #475

Market Analysis

Overview:

  • Domestic Steel Prices: all continued their upward trends, while the HRC 2nd month future took a downturn after advancing for six consecutive weeks.
  • Global Steel Prices: mainly increased, except for Russia’s Export HRC price, which faced a decline.
  • Domestic Steel Production: rebounded to its highest level in four weeks.
  • Steel Imports: are continuing to indicate a notable decline for February’s arrivals. A first look at March’s import arrivals suggest a significant rebound.
  • Raw Materials: Spot prices rose across the board, while their 2nd month futures were mixed.
  • Energy: Futures for crude oil and natural gas fell amid a retreating aggregate inventory level and a stagnant NA rig count.
  • Metals: Base metals mainly faced increases, except for aluminum, while precious metals all experienced advances.
  • Economic Data: This week’s data was light on the industrial side, but covered inflation, sentiment surveys, and the labor market. Overall price pressure moderated in February (potentially due to increased imports), while sentiment soured.

Midwest HRC Spot Price

UPSIDE RISKS:

  • A new tariff Regime – especially when new action is abrupt.
  • Antidumping/Countervailing decision on CORE products
  • Mill outages – maintenance or unplanned, causing a surprise supply side disruption.
  • Supply chain disruptions leading to a temporary shortage and panic buying.
  • Global demand recovery – Chinese stimulus, European rebound, etc.
  • Interest rate cuts leading to an increase in demand and steel related activity.

DOWNSIDE RISKS:

  • Sustained increases to domestic production, overshooting demand.
  • Steel consumers substitute to lower-cost alternatives.
  • Elevated inventories keep a ceiling on any upward momentum.
  • Sustained industrial contraction caused by the FED needing to keep interest rates elevated through the end of 2025.
  • Global manufacturing recession leaks into the U.S.

Steel

U.S. Domestic

The HRC spot price rose by $10 or 1.1% to $950, marking the eighth consecutive week of increases. At the same time, the HRC 2nd month future declined by $13 or -1.4% to $947, ending six consecutive weeks of increases.

Tandem products both increased, with CRC up by $10 and HDG up by $40, resulting in the HDG – HRC differential to jump up by $30 or 20% to $180.

Mill production inched back up, with capacity utilization ticking up by 1.3% to 75.0%, bringing raw steel production up to 1.671m net tons – the highest level in four weeks.

Midwest HRC Spot Price
Midwest HDG – HRC Differential (Monthly Avg.)
AISI Raw Steel Capacity Utilization
Midwest HRC (2nd Month Future)

Imports

March Projection – Sheet 848k (up 108k MoM); Tube 557k (up 227k MoM)

February Projection – Sheet 741k (down 195k MoM); Tube 329k (down 251k MoM)

Differentials

Differentials shrunk mainly due to tariffs. Price changes were: Korea HRC was up 2.0%, China Export HRC was up 0.9%, N Europe HRC was up 1.1%, Turkey Export rose by 0.9%, while Russia Export fell by -1.0%.

Sheet Imports & Tube Imports
Global Differentials (including Transport & Tariffs)

Raw Materials & Freight

Scrap

The busheling 2nd month future fell by $15 or -2.9% to $510, retreating after hitting the highest level since December 2023 last week.

The Aussie coking coal 2nd month future slipped by $7 or -3.6% to $176, marking the third consecutive week of declines and the lowest level since June 2021.

The iron ore 2nd month future inched up by $ 1.85 or 1.8% to $102.10, rebounding after two consecutive weeks of declines.

Dry Bulk / Freight

The Baltic Dry Index increased by $273 or 21.2% to $1,559, rising for the fourth straight week, reaching the highest level since November 2024.

Busheling (2nd Month Future)
Aussie Coking Coal (2nd Month Future)
Iron Ore (2nd Month Future)
Baltic Dry Index

Energy Market

WTI crude oil future lost $0.49 or -0.7% to $66.55/bbl.

WTI natural gas future lost $0.29 or -6.5% to $4.11/bbl.

The aggregate inventory level experienced a decrease of -0.7%.

The Baker Hughes North American rig count held steady at 826 rigs, and similarly, the US rig count remained unchanged at 592 rigs.

Crude Oil (Active Future)
Upload Image...
Natural Gas (Active Future)
Crude, Distillate, & Gas Accumulative Inventory
Rig Count – North American & U.S.

Base Metals

Aluminum futures slipped by $3 or -0.1% to $2,703, as tightening supply from major producers fueled expectations of stronger demand. China’s aluminum production hit a record 44 million tons in 2024, but output is expected to slow significantly this year due to government-imposed production caps. Since 2017, Beijing has maintained a 25-million-ton limit to curb excess supply and support its carbon reduction goals, making a pullback in smelting activity likely. Meanwhile, trade data showed that Chinese aluminum exports remained subdued after the government removed tax rebates on overseas sales. This shift has driven up prices in international markets as domestic producers focus more on supplying local industries. On the demand side, Beijing’s decision to expand its budget deficit to an all-time high signals an aggressive push for economic stimulus, with increased issuance of special bonds expected to bolster infrastructure investment and manufacturing activity—key drivers of aluminum consumption.

Copper futures advanced by $21.55 or 4.6% to $493, as fresh stimulus measures from China fueled expectations of stronger demand in the world’s largest copper consumer. Over the weekend, Beijing announced a policy package aimed at boosting household income, stimulating consumer spending, and addressing population growth challenges—all factors that could drive increased industrial activity and copper consumption. Adding to bullish sentiment, speculation grew that former U.S. President Donald Trump may impose tariffs on copper imports, a move that could exacerbate supply constraints given the limited capacity of domestic smelters. The U.S. currently relies on imports for nearly half of its copper supply, with just two major smelters in operation. While reports suggest such tariffs could be introduced later this year, the White House’s recent decision to raise base metal tariffs on Canadian imports has sparked concerns that copper duties may be implemented sooner than expected, adding further uncertainty to the market.

Precious Metals

Silver grew by $1.50 or 4.6% to $34.32, its highest level since late October, as investors turned to safe-haven assets amid escalating trade tensions and rising expectations of Federal Reserve rate cuts following weaker-than-anticipated U.S. inflation data. Trade uncertainty intensified after former U.S. President Donald Trump threatened to impose 200% tariffs on European wines, champagnes, and other alcoholic beverages in retaliation for the EU’s 50% tariff on American whiskey. Meanwhile, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick sparked debate by suggesting that a potential recession would be a necessary trade-off to implement Trump’s economic policies.

LME Aluminum
CME Copper
Silver

Economic Data

The February Small Business Optimism index decreased to 100.7, down from 102.8 in January, and more than expected 101. The primary driver was the second consecutive increase in the Uncertainty index, now up to 104, just below the record print from October of last year (prior to the election).

February inflation data provided an encouraging signal, coming in below expectations on both the consumer and producer sides. Topline CPI (consumer) rose 0.2% MoM vs. the expected 0.3%, bringing the YoY rate down to 2.8%. Core CPI matched the MoM reading at 0.2% vs. the expected 0.3%, with the YoY rate declining to 3.1% from 3.3% last month. Topline PPI (producer) came in significantly lower than expected at 0.0% MoM, compared to the forecasted 0.3% increase, with the YoY rate at 3.2%. A deeper look suggests this was primarily driven by the surge in imports that continue to make headlines. Adjusting for this, PPI (excluding Food, Energy, & Trade) showed a more moderate improvement, rising 0.2% MoM vs. the expected 0.3%, with a YoY increase of 3.3%.

“Dated” labor market data from January showed an encouraging signal for labor market health, with JOLTS Openings coming in above expectations to 7,740k, signaling increased demand, along with an increase in quits and a decrease in firings. However, more timely indicators suggest that conditions for all three have moderately softened from there. That said, initial jobless claims are holding in the low 200k range, with this week’s data coming in at 220k, below the expected 225k. Continuing claims also improved, decreasing to 1,870k, better than the expected level of 1,888k. It will be important to remember that initial claims will only pick up a minor portion of the government job cuts – given the fact that most have severance pay through August.

Finally, the preliminary March University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Survey retreated further, coming in at 57.9, below the expected decrease to 63 – this is the lowest reading since June 2022. The primary concern coming from the report appears to be increased inflation expectations, with the 5–10-year expectation surging to 3.9%, the highest reading since February 1993.

NFIB Small Business Optimism and Uncertainty
Core CPI & Core PPI (ex. Food & Energy)
JOLTS Job Openings (Thousands)
U. Of Michigan 5-10yr Inflation Expectations