Flack Capital Markets | Ferrous Financial Insider

November 22, 2024 – Issue #459

Market Analysis

There will be no FFI next week, following Thanksgiving.

Overview:

  • Domestic Steel Prices: HRC prices dropped while tandem products held steady. Meanwhile, the HRC 2nd month future declined for the second consecutive week.
  • Global Steel Prices: Globally, steel prices largely fell, leading to further contractions in global price differentials.
  • Steel Production: Raw steel production ticked down, maintaining its subdued level.
  • Steel Imports: Preliminary estimates for October arrivals continue to suggest an increase from September’s final census data. November’s estimated imports suggest some easing.
  • Raw Materials: Raw materials and their 2nd month futures largely faced declines, except for iron ore’s spot price and 2nd month future, which experienced increases.
  • Energy: Crude oil and natural gas futures made gains amid an increased aggregate inventory level and a reduced NA rig count.
  • Metals: Base and precious metals experienced increases across the board.
  • Economic data: This week’s data showed another week of increased optimism for activity in the future, but soft current data. The shift in expectations for lower near-term/higher long-term inflation is notable when considering the FED’s next couple meetings.
Midwest HRC Spot Price

UPSIDE RISKS:

  • Mill outages – maintenance or unplanned, causing a surprise supply side disruption.
  • Interest rate cuts leading to an increase in demand and steel related activity.
  • Supply chain disruptions leading to a temporary shortage and panic buying.
  • Global demand recovery – Chinese stimulus, European rebound, etc.

DOWNSIDE RISKS:

  • Sustained increases to domestic production, overshooting demand.
  • Steel consumers substitute to lower-cost alternatives.
  • Elevated inventories keep a ceiling on any upward momentum.
  • Sustained industrial contraction caused by the FED needing to keep interest rates elevated through the end of the year.
  • Imports remain elevated going into Q4, to get material ahead of trade case decisions, against expectations.

Steel

U.S. Domestic

The HRC spot price declined by $10 or -1.4% to $690, furthering the downtrend in prices that begun six weeks ago. At the same time, the HRC 2nd month future fell by $15 or -2.1% to $695, decreasing for the second consecutive week and hitting the lowest price since August.

Tandem products both remained unchanged, resulting in the HDG – HRC differential to rise by $10 or 6.7% to $160.

Mill production continued to remain subdued, with capacity utilization ticking down by -1.1% to 73.1%, bringing raw steel production down to 1.623m net tons.

Midwest HRC Spot Price
Midwest HDG – HRC Differential (Monthly Avg.)
AISI Raw Steel Capacity Utilization
Midwest HRC (2nd Month Future)

Imports

November Projection – Sheet 879k (down 30k MoM); Tube 411k (up 96k MoM)

October Projection – Sheet 910k (up 69k MoM); Tube 315k (down 58k MoM)

Differentials

Watched global differentials all contracted except for Europe, with the North Europe HRC falling by -2.3%, while the other watched countries declined slighter.

Sheet Imports & Tube Imports
Global Differentials (including Transport & Tariffs)

Raw Materials & Freight

Scrap

The busheling 2nd month future dipped by $5 or -1.1% to $435, bringing the five-week price change to be up by $18 or 4.3%.

The LME Turkish scrap 2nd month future dropped by $16 or -4.4% to $347, marking the second consecutive week of price declines.

The iron ore 2nd month future rose by $3.85 or 3.9% to $102.30, rebounding from last weeks price drop.

Dry Bulk / Freight

The Baltic Dry Index slipped by $14 or -0.9% to $1,616, falling from last weeks price gain.

Busheling (2nd Month Future)
LME Turkish Scrap (2nd Month Future)
Iron Ore (2nd Month Future)
Baltic Dry Index

Energy Market

WTI crude oil future gained $1.40 or 2.0% to $70.10/bbl.

WTI natural gas future gained $0.55 or 19.9% to $3.34/bbl.

The aggregate inventory level experience an up tick, rising by 0.3%.

The Baker Hughes North American rig count reduced by 8 rigs, bringing the total count to 784 rigs. At the same time, the US rig count reduced by 1 rig, bringing the total count to 584 rigs.

Crude Oil (Active Future)
Natural Gas (Active Future)
Crude, Distillate, & Gas Accumulative Inventory
Rig Count – North American & U.S.

Base Metals

Aluminum future climbed by $47.50 or 1.6% to $2,990, driven by supply constraints from major producers and mixed signals about Chinese manufacturing demand. China announced plans to end tax rebates on exports of semi-manufactured aluminum products starting in December, a move estimated to remove approximately five million tonnes of supply from the global market. Meanwhile, bauxite prices surged toward record highs as Guinea, the world’s top exporter, halted shipments from Emirates Global Aluminum. This disruption, compounded by reduced bauxite output in Australia and Jamaica, has severely constrained supply for Chinese smelters, pushing ore inventories to their lowest levels since 2015.

Copper futures edged up by $2.35 or 0.6% to $416. The People’s Bank of China kept key lending rates unchanged, disappointing market expectations for additional stimulus to support economic growth. Meanwhile, global copper inventories continued to shrink due to robust consumption, underscoring steady demand. However, persistent global economic uncertainties are expected to maintain price volatility in the copper market.

Precious Metals

Gold jumped by $126.40 or 4.9% to $2,699. Investors are now focused on the Federal Reserve’s November meeting minutes and upcoming PCE inflation data for clues about the trajectory of U.S. interest rates. Current market sentiment shows a 56% probability of a 25bps rate cut in December, down from 62% last week. Last week, gold surged 6%, driven by heightened safe-haven demand amid escalating tensions in the Russia-Ukraine conflict.

LME Aluminum
CME Copper
Gold

Economic Data

On the industrial side, November data signaled a further contraction in activity from both of this weeks Fed Manufacturing Surveys. Philadelphia was the more disappointment print at -5.5, coming in worse than the anticipated print lower from 10.3 to 8. Kansas City on the other hand was slightly more optimistic, coming in at -2, which while still in contraction territory is better than the expected -5. Furthermore, while the preliminary S&P Global US Manufacturing PMI increased to 48.8, it remains in contraction territory and was slightly below the expected 48.9.

Housing sector data presented an optimistic outlook for the future, while current activity remains hampered by the rise in mortgage rates. There was improved optimism among homebuilders, with the NAHB Housing Market Index rising to 46 in November, surpassing expectations of a decline to 42 to reach the highest level in seven months. However, October’s Housing Starts and Building Permits both fell short of forecasts, with Starts at 1,311k vs the expected 1,334k and Permits at 1,416k vs the expected 1,435k. Meanwhile, Existing Home Sales for October increased to 3.96m, slightly exceeding the anticipated 3.95m.

Finally, the final University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Survey for November rose to 71.8 from 70.5 MoM. While the final data came in below the preliminary estimate it is a clear signal of optimism following the election. Another dynamic that deserves attention is the shift in inflation expectations. After 1yr inflation expectations remained stubbornly high for most of the year, the last 3 months have provided a promising signal of lower expectations – this culminated in todays data, where the figure came in at 2.6%, down from last months print at 2.7%. On the other hand, the longer-term inflation expectations jumped from 3% to 3.2%, matching this cycles all-time high from November 2023. This shift was mirrored by the market’s immediate reaction to Trump’s victory, where longer-term yields rose more significantly than the near-term. This clearly signals a shift towards higher expectations of growth over Trumps administration, but also an increased risk of resurgent inflation which has yet to be fully trounced.

Philadelphia & Kansas City Manufacturing Surveys
NAHB Housing Market Index
Building Permits & Housing Starts